Brian Shaw on Controversy at 2024 Strongest Man on Earth

“The requirements have to be held,” Shaw voiced to his neighborhood on social media.

The 2024 Strongest Man on Earth (SMoE) competitors made historical past with its record-breaking prize purse of $263,200, the most important ever provided within the sport. The champion, Mitchell Hooper, took residence $100,016. 

Regardless of its success, the present wasn’t with out controversy. On Aug. 23, 2024, four-time World’s Strongest Man (WSM) Brian Shaw, the Shaw Traditional‘s namesake promoter, shared an in depth critique and breakdown of the competitors.

Shaw highlighted the 2 occasions that drew probably the most criticism — the overhead medley and squat carry.

[Related: 2024 Shaw Classic Women’s Open Results]

1. Axle Implement Misplacement

Within the overhead medley occasion, every athlete tried to carry a 163-kilogram log, a 170-kilogram axle, a 177-kilogram log, an 184-kilogram axle, and a 191-kilogram log in two minutes.

Nonetheless, after watching the primary 4 athletes battle, Shaw realized there had been a mix-up with the axles. The heavier 184-kilogram axle had been mistakenly positioned earlier than the lighter 170-kilogram one within the sequence.

My greatest disappointment from the competition.

After consulting all of the athletes, the implements have been rearranged within the right order, and the 4 affected athletes have been provided an opportunity to reattempt the occasion in spite of everything different rivals had accomplished their turns.

There is no such thing as a excellent resolution to one thing like this.

Taking full accountability for the oversight, Shaw acknowledged {that a} extra cautious setup might have prevented this error. He expressed his frustration, noting that logistical missteps like these can undermine an athlete’s efficiency, doubtlessly even costing them an occasion and a good shot on the title.

2. Squat Depth Requirements

The second controversy on the 2024 SMoE was Hooper’s unconventional kind through the squat carry occasion. Whereas fellow contestants relied on hip and knee flexion to execute their reps, Hooper primarily employed a hip hinge, sparking debate over the legitimacy of his approach.

Shaw clarified that earlier than the competitors, all rivals acquired an intensive clarification of the foundations, together with private demonstrations from Shaw himself on the required actions and the standards for a sound carry in every occasion.

Shaw highlighted that the SMoE staff documented every athlete’s foot place, knee angle, and bar place on their backs to determine clear benchmarks for judging the lifts. 

[Related: Best Mass Gainer Supplements for Bulking]

Shaw then defined the distinction between powerlifting and strongman squat requirements. In powerlifting, squat depth is often judged by whether or not the lifter’s hip crease descends under the highest of the knees, an ordinary that’s rigorously enforced in competitions.

  • “In strongman, when you get below the equipment, your solely accountability is to take it off the rack, go from the highest to the underside, after which get again up,” Shaw defined. 

Shaw underlined that every athlete adopted a novel method to leverage their power for this occasion. Whereas some maintained an upright torso to maximise glute and quad engagement, others, like Hooper, leaned ahead to leverage their again power.

Shaw revealed that every time the referees had doubts a couple of carry assembly the requirements, they totally reviewed it earlier than deciding. He asserted that each carry awarded within the competitors adhered to the established tips and was judged pretty.

Extra Strongman Content material

Featured picture: @shawstrength on Instagram


Camwood Softball Training Bat – Adult (33-inch)

Camwood Softball Training Bat - Adult (33-inch) Size 33 Inch - 39 Ounce Sport Softball Brand CamWood Bats Material Wood Color Natural Color   About this item Develops Proper Swing Mechanics and Increases Bat Speed Creates...

Easton Elite X Catchers Helmet

Easton Elite X Catchers Helmet Brand Easton Color Black Size Small Special Feature Ventilation Model Name Elite X Catchers Helmet About this item MAXIMUM PROTECTION | ABS Thermoplastic shell with black steel cage is designed...

Easton | JEN SCHRO The Very Best 2.0 Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Equipment | Box Set | NOCSAE Certified | Multiple Sizes/Colors

Easton | JEN SCHRO The Very Best 2.0 Color Black Brand Easton Material Blend Sport Softball Item Dimensions LxWxH 1 x 1 x 1 inches About this item THE VERY BEST BOX SET FROM EASTON...

CHAMPRO Women’s Tournament Traditional Low-Rise Polyester Softball Pant, Small, Black

CHAMPRO Women's Tournament Traditional Low-Rise Polyester Softball Pant, Small, Black Product details Fabric type 100% Polyester Origin Imported Closure type Zipper Rise style Low Rise Country of Origin Ethiopia About this item COMFORTABLE: This modern knicker-style...

Fels Naptha Laundry Soap Bar – 5.0 oz – 2 pk

Fels Naptha Laundry Soap Bar - 5.0 oz - 2 pk Brand Fels Naptha Item Form Bar Scent Unscented Unit Count 10 Ounce Material Type Free Bleach Free About this item Powerful stain remover: Fels...

HotHands Hand Warmers – Long Lasting Safe Natural Odorless Air Activated Warmers – Up to 10 Hours of Heat – 40 Pair

HotHands Hand Warmers About this item SAFE, NATURAL LONG-LASTING HEAT - Odorless, Disposable, Single-Use Item, Do Not Apply Directly to The Skin. TSA Approved. Made...

SKLZ Reaction Ball -Baseball and Softball Reflex and Agility Trainer

SKLZ Reaction Ball -Baseball and Softball Reflex and Agility Trainer Brand SKLZ Material Rubber Color Yellow Age Range (Description) Adult Item Weight 0.09 Kilograms About this item Instant feedback: Get a better analysis of your...

Amazon Basics Easy Grip Workout Dumbbell, Neoprene Coated, Various Sets and Weights available

Amazon Basics Easy Grip Workout Dumbbell Brand Amazon Basics Color Navy Blue Item Weight 20 Pounds Special Feature No Roll Head Use for Hand About this item 10 pound dumbbell (set of 2) for exercise...

Accubat Pro 20 Oz. / 26 Oz. Hitting Aid Baseball/Softball Fungo Racquet Bat

Accubat Pro 20 Oz. / 26 Oz. Size 20oz Sport Softball Brand Accubat Material Fiberglass Color Red About this item Anyone can teach fielding skills with confidence Perfect for the backyard or ballpark, the Coaches'...

Heater Sports Base Hit Lite & Real Baseball Pitching Machine | Great for All Ages for Hitting and Fielding

Heater Sports Base Hit Lite & Real Baseball Pitching Machine About this item PITCHES REAL BASEBALLS FROM 10-45 MPH - The Base Hit Pitching Machine...

DACORM Massage Gun – Percussion Muscle Massage Gun for Athletes, Handheld Deep Tissue Massager, Upgrade Quiet Portable Electric Sport Massager of Y8 Pro Max....

DACORM Massage Gun Use for Back Power Source Battery Powered Material Silicone Item Weight 3.8 Pounds Brand DACORM About this item Massage Gun, equipped with a 3300mAh Lithium battery, lasts from 8-15 hours massage use...

IRON °FLASK Sports Water Bottle – 40 Oz 3 Lids (Straw Lid), Leak Proof – Stainless Steel Gym Bottles for Men, Women & Kids...

IRON °FLASK Sports Water Bottle Brand IRON °FLASK Capacity 2.5 Pounds Color Midnight Black Recommended Uses For Product Water Special Feature Leakproof, Cold 24hrs, Rust resistant, Double wall, Hot 12hrs, Non toxic About this item ...